Top Workers’ Compensation Insurance Companies in California

Overview of California’s Workers’ Compensation Market

• In 2023, California recorded 680,000+ workers’ compensation claims (“first reports of injury”)

• The market is highly profitable, with insurers averaging a 91% combined ratio from 2015–2023 Coverage is mandatory for all employers with employees, and penalties for non-compliance can reach $100,000, fines, or jail time

---

Leading Private Insurers in California

1. State Compensation Insurance Fund (State Fund / SCIF)

• Market leader among insurers in California.

• As a public enterprise fund, it writes policies for ~130,000 policyholders and dominated with nearly 11% market share in earlier years

• Maintains an “open-door” policy, serving high-risk businesses and those unable to secure private coverage

2. Travelers

• The largest U.S. workers’ comp insurer, and a top seller in California.

• Controls around 6.6% national market share (~$3.8 B premiums)

• Known for robust risk-management programs tailored to various industries .

3. The Hartford

• Holds 6.5% U.S. market share ($3.77 B written premiums)

• Praised for its complaint services and safety initiatives.

• Highly rated for small-business affordability: average monthly premiums in California range from $48–$496, depending on business size

4. AmTrust Financial

• Focuses on small- to mid-sized enterprises, with 5.9% national share ($2.4 B)

• Rated A– by AM Best and offers flexible, industry-tailored policies

5. Zenith Insurance

• A California-headquartered specialist owned by Fairfax Financial.

• Among the top 7 California workers’ comp writers

• Strong local relationships and focus on workers’ compensation.

6. Argo Group (formerly Argonaut)

• Founded in California in 1948 as a specialized workers’ comp insurer for the construction industry

• Keeps a strong niche market presence.

7. Zurich & Chubb

• Zurich holds 5% national market share ($2.3 B)

• Along with Chubb, are key national players also active in California

---

Best Value Insurers for California Businesses

According to MoneyGeek (June 2025), the most cost-effective options for small and mid-size firms in California are:

• The Hartford – Score: 99/100, average premium ~$203/month

• biBerk – Score: 91/100, mid-tier premiums

• Nationwide – Score: 91/100

• Pie and Thimble also recommended for cost-conscious buyers

---

Specialized & Niche Providers

• Employers Insurance Company & Preferred Employers Insurance: regional firms thus offering tailored services

• ICW Group, Liberty Mutual: nationally rated providers available to CA businesses

• Progressive and NEXT Insurance: strong digital platforms, noteworthy for small businesses

• Other national carriers include Aetna, Lockton (brokerage), and others with commercial insurance arms

---

✅ What This Means for California Employers

• State Fund is ideal for those unable to secure private insurance.

• Travelers & Hartford excel in safety services and claims management.

• Zenith offers CA-focused expertise.

• For small businesses, The Hartford, biBerk, Nationwide balance cost and service.

• If tech-driven processes matter, providers like NEXT and Progressive may be preferred.

---

Final Takeaways

1. Mandatory Compliance: All California employers must carry coverage or face significant legal penalties

2. Market Leaders: State Fund leads statewide; Travelers and Hartford dominate at national scale.

3. Value Picks: Hartford, biBerk, Nationwide stand out cost-wise for small/mid-size firms.

4. Specialized Capacity: Zenith, Argo, Employers Ins. excel in niche coverage.

5. Digital-first Carriers: NEXT and Progressive offer online convenience.

---

Pro Tips for Choosing a Provider

• Evaluate data-driven risk management and safety programs.

• Compare premium estimates for your specific business class code.

• Review claim-service reputation, including handling speeds and support.

• Check financial ratings (e.g., AM Best).

• Ensure full California compliance, including pay-as-you-go options and certificate access.