Women Leaders in Insurance in the USA: Paving the Way for a More Inclusive Industry
The insurance industry in the United States, once dominated almost exclusively by men, has witnessed a powerful transformation in recent decades. Today, women leaders are not only shaping the future of the insurance sector—they are driving innovation, steering corporate growth, and championing diversity and inclusion across the board.
The Rise of Women in Insurance Leadership
Women have steadily been making their mark in all areas of insurance—from underwriting and claims to executive roles and boardrooms. According to data from the Insurance Industry Charitable Foundation (IICF), women now make up over 60% of the insurance workforce in the U.S. However, representation in executive leadership has traditionally lagged behind.
That dynamic is changing. A new wave of female executives, entrepreneurs, and trailblazers are proving that gender is no barrier to success in this complex and fast-evolving field.
Pioneering Women Leaders in Insurance
1. Tricia Griffith – CEO, Progressive Insurance
Tricia Griffith became the first female CEO of a major U.S. insurance company when she was appointed to lead Progressive in 2016. Under her leadership, Progressive has seen substantial growth and has become one of the most innovative and tech-forward insurers in the country. Griffith was named Fortune’s Businessperson of the Year in 2018 and has championed workplace inclusion and digital transformation.
2. Susan MacMichael John – Former President, NAIFA
Susan MacMichael John was a trailblazer in the financial and insurance advisory industry. As one of the first women to hold a top leadership role at the National Association of Insurance and Financial Advisors (NAIFA), she paved the way for women in insurance financial services.
3. Lori Goltermann – Chief Client Officer, Aon
Lori Goltermann has spent her career at Aon, rising through the ranks to become Chief Client Officer and CEO of Aon North America. She has led transformative initiatives around client service and strategy, particularly in risk management and human capital.
4. Jennifer Fitzgerald – Co-founder and CEO, Policygenius
As co-founder of the insurtech startup Policygenius, Jennifer Fitzgerald is among a growing group of female entrepreneurs revolutionizing how consumers shop for insurance online. She has been recognized by Inc., Fast Company, and Forbes for her innovation and leadership in the digital insurance space.
5. Kirsten Marr – CMO, Insurity
Kirsten Marr is known for her work in leveraging data analytics and AI to improve decision-making and customer engagement within the insurance industry. As a marketing and strategy leader, she’s an advocate for using technology to close the customer expectation gap.
The Importance of Diversity in Insurance
A diverse leadership team fosters better decision-making, more creative problem-solving, and stronger financial performance. According to a McKinsey report, companies with gender-diverse executive teams are 25% more likely to outperform their peers on profitability. The insurance industry, which thrives on managing risk and understanding diverse customer needs, benefits significantly from inclusive leadership.
Many major insurers are now doubling down on Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) programs. Organizations such as the Women’s Insurance Networking Group (WING), Association of Professional Insurance Women (APIW), and IICF have played vital roles in mentorship, sponsorship, and leadership development for women in the sector.
Challenges That Persist
Despite significant progress, barriers remain:
-
Leadership Gap: While women are well represented at entry and mid-level positions, they are underrepresented in C-suite roles.
-
Pay Inequity: Gender pay gaps still persist in many areas of the insurance industry.
-
Lack of Sponsorship: Many women cite a lack of access to influential sponsors or mentors to help them advance their careers.
Overcoming these challenges requires a sustained industry-wide effort to prioritize inclusive leadership development, equitable policies, and transparent opportunities for advancement.
Future Outlook
The future is bright for women in insurance. The rise of insurtech, changing consumer behavior, and a greater emphasis on ESG (Environmental, Social, Governance) principles are aligning with values and competencies often brought to the table by diverse leadership teams.
Initiatives such as:
-
Women in Insurance Awards & Conferences
-
Global Women in Insurance Networking
-
Internal Leadership Development Programs at Companies like Allstate, Liberty Mutual, and Travelers
… are accelerating change and inspiring the next generation of female leaders.
Conclusion
Women leaders in the insurance industry are redefining what leadership looks like in a historically male-dominated space. From CEOs of Fortune 500 companies to innovative insurtech founders and C-suite strategists, these women are proving that inclusive leadership is smart business.
The U.S. insurance industry has made great strides, but continued progress will depend on intentional action—nurturing talent, promoting equity, and creating a culture where women can lead authentically and powerfully.
FAQs
1. What percentage of leadership roles in insurance are held by women in the U.S.?
Approximately 23% of executive roles in U.S. insurance firms are held by women, despite women representing over 60% of the total workforce.
2. Who was the first female CEO of a major U.S. insurance company?
Tricia Griffith of Progressive Insurance was the first woman to serve as CEO of a major U.S. auto insurer.
3. What organizations support women in insurance?
Groups like the Women’s Insurance Networking Group (WING), Association of Professional Insurance Women (APIW), and the Insurance Industry Charitable Foundation (IICF) support mentorship, leadership, and networking opportunities.
4. What are the main barriers for women in insurance leadership?
Common challenges include the leadership pipeline gap, lack of mentorship, unconscious bias, and pay inequity.
5. How can the insurance industry improve gender diversity?
Implementing leadership development programs, enforcing equitable hiring and promotion practices, and fostering inclusive corporate cultures are key strategies.
